Great good for a great price! Atmosphere was a little much for me. It that was just my personal taste. Food was excellent and the service was amazing. - 4/19/2024 

Love this place, only thing when I order for pick-up my orders are always wrong. - 4/16/2024 

- 4/16/2024 

Top notch food. Service was excellent. The cleanliness of this restaurant is above great. The food was fresh and delicious. - 4/14/2024 

- 4/14/2024 

- 4/05/2024 

- 3/31/2024 

- 3/25/2024 

This is our favorite place for certain! The food is outstanding. The service is above and beyond wonderful! And the serving sizes are perfect for everyone! Some eat everything at the restaurant and I have a bedtime snack! ❤️ - 3/24/2024 

- 3/23/2024 

- 3/11/2024 

Great food with large portions. Great staff and environment. - 2/29/2024 

great food great price. To go is usually 10 min - 2/27/2024 

- 2/27/2024 

- 2/27/2024 

One of the best Mexican Restaurants in Columbus. Food is delicious. The price is affordable even for a family meal. Atmosphere is peaceful and pleasant. - 2/26/2024 

- 2/19/2024 

- 2/19/2024 

Friendly and food is always great! - 2/02/2024 

- 1/28/2024 

- 1/26/2024 

Staff so eager to make sure everything is great! - 1/21/2024 

- 1/16/2024 

- 1/14/2024 

- 1/14/2024 

- 1/14/2024 

GREAT food! It's only about 5 mintues of I-65 so it's WORTH IT. Stop and eat here. You won't regret it. - 1/06/2024 

Super nice and good food - 1/06/2024 

One of the best Mexican restaurants I have ever been to. Great service, great food. Will definitely be returning. - 12/30/2023 

best around. service is top notch and the food is amazing - 12/15/2023 

- 12/15/2023 

Excellent food and service - 12/11/2023 

Place is amazing - 12/10/2023 

- 12/06/2023 

Hosted a party of 16 there. Silvestre did a great job taking care of us and keeping our drinks filled. - 12/05/2023 

Stopped in from out of town. Food was great. Service was on point even though it was late on a weekday. Didn't feel rushed at all. Great local joint. - 12/03/2023 

- 12/02/2023 

- 11/23/2023 

Great food nice atmosphere and great margaritas 🍹 - 11/19/2023 

- 11/17/2023 

Food was very good. Service was excellent! - 11/13/2023 

Great mexican food,great service. - 11/12/2023 

- 11/12/2023 

Very fast great service - 11/11/2023 

- 11/07/2023 

Always good service and good food. - 11/05/2023 

- 11/03/2023 

Grate place, delicious food, grate hospitality. - 10/27/2023 

Seguramente voy a volver para probar otravez el caldo de pescado! Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 4/5 - 10/24/2023 

- 10/15/2023 

- 9/30/2023 

Food was delicious and service was quick. I wish there was an El Potro near where I live. Highly recommend anyone in the area to stop by and give this place a try. - 9/25/2023 

- 9/21/2023 

- 9/19/2023 

Super sabroso y muy buena la atención - 9/18/2023 

- 9/15/2023 

- 9/15/2023 

- 9/14/2023 

Try the Burrito Trio. Steak, Shrimp & Chicken... Delicious - 9/12/2023 

- 9/09/2023 

Love this place - 8/28/2023 

- 8/28/2023 

Best Mexican restaurant around. Authentic food and great service. - 8/26/2023 

This restaurant is a hidden gem. Excellent service, delicious food, pleasant atmosphere. I greatly enjoyed my dinner there. Those Mango margaritas are a hit! Highly recommend this place! - 8/24/2023 

Great! They have a vast menu, the food is great, and the service was on point. This is now one of my favorite restaurants to go. - 8/22/2023 

está muy bien las comidas 👍👍👍👍 - 8/21/2023 

This is a delightful little Mexican restaurant in downtown Edinburgh. The atmosphere is lovely, lots of colorful painted wood everywhere. The food is always very good and fresh and the service is top notch. You never have to ask for a drink refill, the staff are very prompt, attentive and friendly! - 8/14/2023 

- 8/11/2023 

Bright restaurant. The staff is super friendly and kind. The food?? Oh my god. It is one of the best Mexican restaurants I have come across. I definitely recommend eating here, but it's not the best guacamole I've had by far, so there's that. - 8/09/2023 

- 8/05/2023 

Great food great drinks priced well - 8/04/2023 

- 7/30/2023 

My hubby & I love this place. Always great food - and plenty of it, friendly & prompt service. And, the decor makes you almost feel like you've stopped at a cantina in Mexico. - 7/27/2023 

- 7/25/2023 

We eat at a lot of Mexican restaurants and this is by far and away the best. The food was very tasty and generously sized servings. And the prices were very modest. 10 out of 10! - 7/24/2023 

Always easy to get in and out of during lunch time and with the chips and salsa and meal it is very affordable! Paired with great taste... hard to pass up! - 7/21/2023 

Primera vez que vengo a comer con mi familia y nos gusto mucho ala 4 es Lugar muy bonito sobre todo muy limpio muy amable el mesero la comida muy buena volveríamos a elegir - 7/17/2023 

Beautiful remodel of this restaurant. Food authentic with a wide variety menu. Service was superb, efficient and kind staff. We enjoyed our first visit and it won't be our last! - 7/10/2023 

- 7/09/2023 

I 100% recommend this place. Good taste of the food two years ago I moved to Indy and I had not found a restaurant with that flavor. very friendly staff - 7/08/2023 

Honestly i was intimidated by the amount of food there was brought to my table. The food was phenomenal. Literally jaw Gazamic. Service was fun and friendly. The atmosphere was vibrant and wholesome. Definitely made my fav list. Thank you guys we will be back. - 7/06/2023 

The food was amazing service was great looking forward to going back very soon - 7/06/2023 

- 7/02/2023 

- 7/02/2023 

Always great food and drinks. Love this place. - 6/24/2023 

- 6/24/2023 

From the street, this restaurant looks like a carry-out, but it has a number of seats and tables. For a small town, El Potro is a great eatery. My brother, my daughter, and my granddaughter dined her and had a grand experience. Parking: Small lot but today was easy to park as not super-busy. - 6/22/2023 

- 6/19/2023 

- 6/16/2023 

Wrong turn ended in a great lunch. Great food and service. - 6/03/2023 

Great food and service. We'll be back. - 6/03/2023 

I have eaten here with friends 3 separate times and it has always been a great meal, service and atmosphere. Highly recommend - 5/29/2023 

- 5/18/2023 

Finally, a Mexican restaurant near me that offers chicken soup! It was very good. The salsa here is also one of my favorites. - 5/17/2023 

Very good. Great staff - 5/16/2023 

Very nice ambiance. The food is excellent. I go there often and always get great service. The prices are also excellent. They offer a really nice selection of drinks as well. - 5/15/2023 

Food was fire! No complaints from our table at all. The waiter was really friendly. - 5/14/2023 

If you live in Edinburgh you probably already know about this place. I was visiting and it blew me away with how good it was. I'm thinking of reasons right now on why to come back to Indiana because it was so good. - 5/13/2023 

Best Mexican food around!! Staff is so nice and the service is GREAT! Kid-friendliness: My child makes a mess every time he eats rice. 90% of it ends up on the ground. Every time I ask for a broom to sweep it up and never once have they let me. It never seems to bother them. They speak to my son and play with him ever time we are there! The kids menu have some great options as well! - 5/07/2023 

The BEST chicken soft tacos I've ever had!!!! - 5/05/2023 

- 5/05/2023 

- 5/04/2023 

- 5/04/2023 

- 5/04/2023 

These people are awesome. They accomodate everything possible to make sure you leave with a smile. I would recommend this place to anyone who wants a good meal at a good price and wants excellent customer service. - 4/26/2023 

First thing we noticed was it was Warm inside (50 degrees outside) and the colorful artwork on the walls, ceiling, and furniture. The food was very tasty. Seasoned well. The service was fast and friendly. I ordered the California burrito, lunch portion. Needed a box. I'm sure would need a box for the dinner portion too. Very much liked this place and will visit again if ever in the area. Parking: Enough for the location and can park on the street if necessary - 4/25/2023 

Beautiful, colorful, great food, great customer service. A must if you're in the area! - 4/25/2023 

The food was really good and the place was empty which I found surprising - 4/25/2023 

Enchiladas verdes and strawberry margaritas were excellent! - 4/25/2023 

Up to snuff - 4/25/2023 

- 4/22/2023 

Very good place to go for authentic food and very reasonably priced! - 4/14/2023 

We love el Potro. We're so lucky to have them in the community. The food is fantastic. Drinks are festive. Staff is top notch. Never had a bad experience in eight years. - 4/04/2023 

Service is fantastic! Food is delicious and accommodating to vegetarians. Staff is always friendly! Highly recommend. - 4/04/2023 

- 4/02/2023 

- 3/29/2023 

- 3/28/2023 

My family and I had a great time! There were six of us eating. The service was amazing! It was a very clean place. The food was over the top. Everything we ordered looked and tasted amazing! I was shocked how fast our order came in. The waiter was polite and pre bused all night. I would highly recommend this place to anyone. - 3/27/2023 

Good food , fair prices and great staff - 3/26/2023 

I always get take out. It’s always VERY fast and the staff is always kind and quick! - 3/21/2023 

- 3/20/2023 

We try to get in there at least once a week. The Food is always fresh and excellently prepared. The restaurant is cleaner than it has ever been. And the staff are all super friendly and good at what they do! They keep us coming back week after week! - 3/10/2023 

Good food and restaurant is clean! - 3/10/2023 

- 3/09/2023 

We really enjoyed our night here. It was a good clean atmosphere, with pleasant staff. And we enjoyed our meal as well. - 3/06/2023 

- 3/05/2023 

Food and Service are always top notch! Drinks are always great as well! Vegetarian options: Tty the country salad without meat.. DELICIOUS! Kid-friendliness: Several kid options and fun atmosphere - 3/04/2023 

Food is great, fresh, hot flavorful. The service is good but sometimes they seem understaffed. - 3/04/2023 

A step above in quality of food and service, than your typical Mexican restaurant. - 3/04/2023 

- 3/03/2023 

- 2/27/2023 

- 2/27/2023 

Great restaurant, amazing service I couldn't finish the burrito but food was delicious. I will always go to this restaurant. - 2/25/2023 

Tuesday tacos 99 cents - 2/21/2023 

This has been some of the best food around. If you have never been you are missing out - 2/20/2023 

- 2/20/2023 

Great mexican food in a small town out of the way strip mall. The menu is large and suited to just about any mexican dish you can imagine. Staff is happy to adjust items on the menu for you as well. Drinks were awesome. I had enchiladas that were out of this world good and thierbcrispy beef taco was loaded with meat. Will go again when I the area. - 2/18/2023 

Fast friendly service Great food competitive prices you definitely get what you pay for - 2/15/2023 

This used to be another Mexican restaurant that was horrible 😕 but the new owners did a great job fixing and cleaning the place AND the food is really good. You pay a little more for it but worth it to us. - 2/12/2023 

Best Mexican restaurant around. The food is great. The service is wonderful and people are nice. The margaritas are generous. - 2/08/2023 

We made a stop for dinner at El Potro after shopping at Edinburgh premium outlet - Indian. The ambience and food are superb - the Tilapia El Porto and Camerones A La Diablo were supreme flavors and generous quantities. We love a good spice with our Indian descent and El Potro did not disappoint. The Mexican flavors were authentic and the portions were size-able. The sea food dishes were the best in terms of flavors and protein quantity. Overall a great place to visit though it has a heavy local vibe. Vegetarian options: We ordered vegetarian 1 and 2 which had vegetables, black beans and tortillas Kid-friendliness: Lots of kids at El Potro although drinks were also being served Parking: Sufficient and generous parking - 2/04/2023 

- 2/04/2023 

Get a lot of food for price. People are always friendly. Service is amazing and quick. - 1/21/2023 

- 1/21/2023 

Great service great atmosphere great food always Great place to eat we eat there often - 1/11/2023 

Best bang for your buck, by far. I've never been disappointed eating here - 1/11/2023 

Fast, Delicuous and visibly appetizing!!! Love this place ♥️♥️♥️ - 1/11/2023 

Great food. Prompt service and excellent selection. - 1/11/2023 

A great place to eat and good pricing - 1/11/2023 

Shrimp Fajitas were awesome!!! - 1/11/2023 

- 12/11/2022 

It's very hard to find a Midwest Mexican restaurant that doesn't use the same tired menu all the others use. El Potro has managed to be the exception. Nestled on the corner of a small, sleepy, downtown street of Edinburgh, IN, El Potro might be easily missed, if not for the reserved flair of pictures of horses (personally owned by one of the co-owners, who just happen to be cousins) in the windows. You first walk in and, as a first-time guest, you're surprised by the energy of the patrons and staff alike. Nobody is exceptionally loud, but the buzz is almost like a family get-together during the holidays. You're seated, then presented with the ever-present chips and salsa. You begrudgingly take a bite, then pause, scoop more salsa, and you're taste buds explode with flavor. This isn't no mama casa salsa the others use. This salsa hints of roasted poblano, green chili's, and other smoky, earthy, just spicy enough to tingle, notes of deliciousness. I'm not afraid to say that I was tempted to lick the bowl clean. I'm going to stop here, because I'm not being paid for this review. If you want to know more, I suggest taking a trip to little Edinburgh, IN and discovering El Potro, and it's awesome staff, yourself. - 11/11/2022 

We had the chicken fajitas. It was so big my husband and I split it. It was absolutely delicious. Down to the chips and salsa. And queso. It was so so good. 8 ordered the mango margarita on the rocks. With top shelf tequila which was Patron. My husband got the regular house margarita. It was lime-ey.. the food and atmosphere was so great. I wish this place was closer to home. Because this would be one of our regular spots. I locked my keys in car. These gentlemen here were so so nice they were so quick to help us. I mean to stop what they were doing to help us was just incredible. I wish I lived out here. Everyone is kind. And so willing to help out when they see someone in need. I think 3-4 people that left the restaurant asked Javier if he needed help. I mean I live in Southport and not many people would ask that if they seen us trying to get into car. Best Mexican restaurant EVER!!! BEST PEOPLE EVER!!! BEST FOOD EVER!!! DEFINITELY A 10 ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ RESTAURANT... THANK YOU EL POTRO... MY FAVORITE RESTAURANT BY FAR!!! - 11/11/2022 

Best service I have had in a long time and the food is delicious. I live in Bloomington, but will be making the trip again soon just for this food. - 11/11/2022 

Vegetarian options: We did not need this Kid-friendliness: Love these guys always nice ànd polite - 11/11/2022 

- 11/11/2022 

Very fast service, the food was right, and they make their own tortilla shells Parking: Large parking lot for a small town - 10/11/2022 

El Potro is a great place for Tex-Mex. Friendly service, good prices and good location. - 10/11/2022 

Muy buen luges buenas atención muy buenas comida … 100% recomendado - 10/11/2022 

Great restaurant with outstanding food and service - 10/11/2022 

The food and service was awesome as always - 10/11/2022 

Delicious food, fast and friendly service. - 10/11/2022 

Food was delicious - 10/11/2022 

Good food oo - 10/11/2022 

- 10/11/2022 

- 10/11/2022 

Amazing little Mexican restaurant. Everything was very clean and the service staff were all professional and polite. I had the la diabla tacos both times that I went and they were consistent and delicious both times. Will be going back again - 9/11/2022 

Parking: Needs better parking. They are on corner and by gestation so it's hard to park sometimes. There busy because food and service is amazing. So dealing with parking is worth it. It would just make it that more awesome. - 9/11/2022 

They gave us plenty of food for the price we paid it was perfect. The service was fast and our waiter was super nice. - 9/11/2022 

We’re from out of town and came here with our family. The food was great! Very large portions. Service was amazing! - 9/11/2022 

Come here almost every time Im in Nineveh. Always hot, fresh, tasty food with great service. - 9/11/2022 

Food was delicious. Nice size portions. Service was great. Highly recommend. - 9/11/2022 

People very friendly and efficient. Very fresh and tasty food. - 9/11/2022 

Best Mexican food in the county and the service is great. - 9/11/2022 

Great Food and margaritas are phenomenal - 9/11/2022 

Quick, friendly service. Food was good. - 9/11/2022 

Good food and customer service! - 9/11/2022 

- 9/11/2022 

- 9/11/2022 

- 9/11/2022 

- 9/11/2022 

Love the food here and the margaritas are pretty big and amaizing. The staff was supper friendly and the food was super quick. - 8/11/2022 

This is a hidden gem in Edinburgh. Definitely recommend the supreme quesadilla. Amazing food! - 8/11/2022 

Best Mexican joint around Vegetarian options: Options for everyone Parking: A lot of space - 8/11/2022 

Great local mexican restaurant. They treat me well and the food is great! - 8/11/2022 

Wonderful food and drinks and the service is consistently top notch.👌 - 8/11/2022 

Great food and service! BEST MARGARITAS IN TOWN!!!! - 8/11/2022 

Wonderful food and good service and great company. - 8/11/2022 

Friendly staff. Great food. Excellent margaritas - 8/11/2022 

Great food and service!! Definitely 5 stars! - 8/11/2022 

Great service and food. - 8/11/2022 

Friendly staff - 8/11/2022 

- 8/11/2022 

- 8/11/2022 

Fun place, delicious food - 7/11/2022 

yum - 7/11/2022 

- 7/11/2022 

- 7/11/2022 

I eat here all the time! Whether inside or to go. The staff is always great. It’s very welcoming and because of our small community, they tend to “know” most of the patrons. The food is awesome. If something isn’t right (rarely happens) they fix it. I can’t say enough good things about this place. Oh and the drinks are strong unlike some places that skimp on the alcohol - 6/11/2022 

Hand down great Mexican food around. - 6/11/2022 

Excellent food, great staff. - 6/11/2022 

- 6/11/2022 

- 6/11/2022 

Great food and excellent service! - 5/11/2022 

Great food, friendly hosts. - 5/11/2022 

Good food and well priced. - 5/11/2022 

Great service and food! - 5/11/2022 

Love the food here - 5/11/2022 

Friendly and good - 5/11/2022 

Good service - 5/11/2022 

- 5/11/2022 

I moved to Nineveh in 2021 and El Potro is just 8 minutes from my home. I have eaten there thirty times since then and it's a great Mexican Restaurant!!.. the staff is dedicated and respectful and the food has always been top shelf!.. El Potro is the best food in Nineveh... might just be the best Spanish cuisine I've ever eaten... Kudos to the owners and the cooks at this 5 star eatery. - 4/11/2022 

Dude just go here! There is no better Mexican cuisine with in 100 miles guaranteed! Probably more.So glad this group somehow ended up here in small town Indiana allowing us this badass food! Been going here for about 4 years now and have never ever left disappointed. Get some drinks while your there they are always great! - 4/11/2022 

Who was highly recommend this place to anyone who wants good food. Service is great. It is a nice comfortable place to eat at great food. Will go back again and take all my friends that wanted to go. Highly recommend - 4/11/2022 

Good food and good service. Loved it. - 4/11/2022 

- 4/11/2022 

- 4/11/2022 

My wife and I stopped by at dinner time on a Thursday. The service was great. The decor is nice. The quality and quantity of food is amazing. This place is a must try. We will be returning. - 3/11/2022 

Truly good food. These are not canned beans like the majority of other restaurants. They season perfectly. Best restaurant for Mexican food around. - 3/11/2022 

Great food and great staff! - 3/11/2022 

- 3/11/2022 

- 3/11/2022 

Pros: Authentic Mexican great tasting food; excellent Horchata; Excellent Salsa!!!!! Great staff!!! Cons: none!!! Overall: This place is by far the best Mexican food place outside of Mexico! I ordered the "fajitas de lujo" and the portions were out of control!!! The Horchata was perfect!!! I highly recommend this place to anyone looking to get authentic Mexican food!!! 10 out of ten. - 2/11/2022 

Wow! What a cool little place. I make it a point to find at least one Mexican restaurant in every city I'm in. I talked with the staff en Español. I was going through a really difficult time, muy duro (ahhh, mi corazón, you remember guys lol). Things are going much better for me these days by the way. Anyway, I HIGHLY recommend checking this place out. - 2/11/2022 

Fast and friendly service!! The restaurant it self is nice inside, i love the round lights that are above the table's! Reasonable price's on their food and not to mention the food is delicious!! Their frozen margarita's are the bomb!! Great place for family to go and have a dinner night!! - 2/11/2022 

I came to this area for some training. While here I stopped by this joint and boy was it worth the stop. Friendly staff, great environment and the tacos were on point. I recommend carnitas, al pastor, and steak in that order. Def would recommend and would stop by again. - 2/11/2022 

This is the most friendly and best food in all of Indiana. I came in by myself and was very comfortable and had many of the staff speak to me. They really made me feel welcomed Thank you so much for your excellent service - 2/11/2022 

Love this restaurant, people are nice, food is great, service is impeccable, prices are good , honestly can't say enough good things - 2/11/2022 

Great place, great food, great staff!! These folks have done a great job with this place, and the community loves the food!! - 2/11/2022 

Food is amazing, highly recommend the super quesadilla. Great service, would definitely bring family and friends here. - 2/11/2022 

Clean establishment upbeat atmosphere. The waiters care about their customers and their jobs. Polite and friendly - 2/11/2022 

Excelente comida mexicana... buen ambiente, amable atencion y sobre todo la calidad de la comida!! Recomendado!! - 2/11/2022 

Good food and very good service. I'm glad they are there and are able to handle larger groups as they come in. - 2/11/2022 

Great staff, fast service, and great food. Would recommend this to anyone who enjoys Mexican food. - 2/11/2022 

Always great service and great food. They don't disappoint. They have also made a nice bar area! - 2/11/2022 

Excellent food wonderful atmosphere dine in or carry out I am addicted to their shrimp enchiladas - 2/11/2022 

Have ate there 10+ times and have never had a bad experience. Great drinks and awesome service - 2/11/2022 

I love this place good food great atmosphere and the people make you feel like family - 2/11/2022 

My favorite Authentic Mexican place to eat. It is so good. Great service and fast. - 2/11/2022 

Love the service we get everytime we go in. Very good food and good company - 2/11/2022 

We absolutely love this Mexican restaurant! Gret food,service and atmosphere! - 2/11/2022 

Quick and friendly service - Javier is great! Delicious and hefty portions. - 2/11/2022 

Love this place. Great food and nice staff. Cadillac margaritas are bomb. - 2/11/2022 

My favorite restaurant in Nineveh! They always cater to my picky self. 😊 - 2/11/2022 

Great, affordable food. Beto, Javier, Augustin, are all wonderful. - 2/11/2022 

Always quick friendly service and very good authentic Mexican food. - 2/11/2022 

Food was delicious and service was excellent. We will be back. - 2/11/2022 

Excellent food. Wonderful service. Very fair prices. - 2/11/2022 

We have finally found a go to Mexican restaurant - 2/11/2022 

Quick, good and reasonably priced! I'll be back - 2/11/2022 

Food was delicious and service was very good - 2/11/2022 

Good food. .Communication could be better. - 2/11/2022 

very great food and the staff are amazing - 2/11/2022 

Delicious food and wonderful service!! - 2/11/2022 

Food and service is always great. - 2/11/2022 

Good food Great margaritas!! - 2/11/2022 

Awesome food, Great service. - 2/11/2022 

Good food friendly service - 2/11/2022 

Good food & great service! - 2/11/2022 

Great food friendly staff - 2/11/2022 

Excellent and good price - 2/11/2022 

Best Mexican food ever. - 2/11/2022 

Great food and service. - 2/11/2022 

Was absolutely great - 2/11/2022 

Super Fast service - 2/11/2022 

Always good! - 2/11/2022 

Delicious 😋 - 2/11/2022 

Great food! - 2/11/2022 

Great food - 2/11/2022 

Yummy - 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022 

- 2/11/2022